CD Feature/ Valery Gergiev & LSO: "Mahler - Symphony No. 1"
TobiasDiscarding the proliferating canon of facts, factoids and myths as well as psycholgical and philosophical theories, Gergiev’s Mahler is a raw block of stone composed of a single element: Sound. Sculpted into rhythmic staccatos, soft sheets of subtle harmonics, epic walls of piercing noise, filigree melodies or malleable dance patterns, it takes on various shapes and guises over the course of this disc but never looses its primeaval, elemental and transcendental character. Gergiev cares little for the composer’s personal background and approaches his oeuvre from the perspective of a naive listener: Personal perception, instead of historical reception is the key to understanding the music here.
The stunning physical effectiveness of the drastic dynamics displayed on this live recording show that he has a point. The crescendi and fortes are of a shattering, adrenalising intensity while the bronzen timbres of the LSO’s brass radiate a consoling warmth and ooze a concentrative power constantly at the brink of exploding. Textures are occasionally more important than thematic development, such as in the opening passage of the first movement, when the otherworldly hum of the strings seems to be the catalyst for the gradually awakening orchestral sections. With regards to Mahler’s love for metaphors drawn from nature, this preference of the immediately palpable over the metaphysically constructed makes sense from an interpretational stance as well.
There are plenty of exciting moments in the first three movements, enough to keep you glued to your seat at any rate. Especially the dirge-like canon offers an interesting new perspective, its characteristical Jewish folk elements appearing less as satirical here and rather as flashbacks, as lapses into distant memories and an opaque past. All of this, however, is nothing but mere preparation for the grand finale, in which Gergiev throws all motives into a bewildering maelstrom of frenzied propulsiveness, recreating the music anew from scratch and uniting even the most antithetic strands. The last minutes are nothing less than a euphorical triumph, a last scream before lapsing into silence.
Every decision in favour of one thing automatically implies negating another, of course. While the dynamitic explosiveness of the LSO and their tight and direct sound turn this recording into an overwhelming sensory experience, the dream-like qualities of Mahler’s aural imagery are slightly lost in the turbulences. The instruments seldomly merge into a deep, threedimensional canvas, opting for a transparent, analytical tone instead. Gergiev’s interpretation is not a programmatic fantasy anymore, but a very real statement of intent, which will disappoint all those who enjoyed the escapist tendencies of the work. Once again, not everyone will be pleased. With Mahler, though, that can hardly register as serious criticism.
By Tobias Fischer
Homepage: LSO
Related articles
Concert Review/ Royal Concertgebouw Orchestra & Mariss Jansons & Jill Grove
Live at Carnegie Hall, New ...
2010-03-12
Live at Carnegie Hall, New ...
2010-03-12
Anna Netrebko: 'Souvenirs' focusses on Operetta, extends friendship
Russian Soprano Anna Netrebko is ...
2008-10-23
Russian Soprano Anna Netrebko is ...
2008-10-23
Sol Gabetta: Cantabile and Shostakovich Double-Strike
Argentinian-born Franco-Russian Cellist Sol Gabetta ...
2008-08-08
Argentinian-born Franco-Russian Cellist Sol Gabetta ...
2008-08-08
15 Questions to Barbara Kuster/Asasello Quartett
For the past decades, internationalism ...
2008-08-05
For the past decades, internationalism ...
2008-08-05
Pierre Boulez: Contract with Deutsche Grammophon extended
Pierre Boulez has announced that ...
2007-12-20
Pierre Boulez has announced that ...
2007-12-20